Indie Bound Amazon Barnes & Noble Flux
Lisa’s query critique …
Query #12:
Dear,
Seventeen-year-old Zoe has met the girl of her dreams—as long as she can ignore the fangs and fur. This is a great opening—fun and unexpected.
Zoe couldn’t care less when super-popular Ryan chats her up this phrase feels odd—hits on her? Asks her out?. Any other girl would be flattered, why is she not flattered? Because she’s already not interested in guys? Because of who he is, as a person? but when her rejection sinks in, he corners her, not willing to take no for an answer. She escapes by fleeing how can she flee if she’s cornered? into the woods, only to wind up hopelessly lost.
Exhausted and afraid, she stumbles across an isolated mansion and Isabella—a cursed girl who’s had no human contact in years, afraid that revealing herself would land her in a lab. Don’t rush this. Who cursed her/how did she get cursed? What IS the curse—just the fur and horns? Why is she afraid of a lab instead of being killed for being a monster? Zoe finds herself drawn to her, despite her furry body and curled horns. Why? Does Isabella give her a place to stay? Is she kind? Does Zoe want to be drawn? Has she ever been drawn to another girl before? What about the girl with the horns is appealing to Zoe?
Zoe searches for a way to break the curse again, why? Is it only because she’s drawn to her?—but that’s not the only thing on her mind. Ryan is hounding her to drop the charges she filed against him. 1) this sounds like much more than being “cornered” and 2)So she doesn’t stay in the woods? I thought she was hopelessly lost? When he discovers Isabella, he threatens to expose her to the world, but Zoe doesn’t think Ryan’s revenge will end there. What else is she afraid of? These are your big stakes, right? You might want this to be a bit less vague. To protect the girl she loves, Zoe must break the curse before Isabella is locked away in a lab. this phrase echoes the one above. Try to revise, to eliminate the repetition.
SKIN DEEP is a 57,000 word young adult paranormal romance retelling of Beauty and the Beast. Thank you for your time and consideration.
Sincerely,
This sounds like an interesting twist to the Beauty and the Beast tale, but I feel like I’m missing the heart of your story. For Beauty and the Beast, the heart of the tale has to do with the relationship between the girl and the beast—she discovers that he can be kind and human despite his fur and she learns to look beyond her own short-sightedness. But in this query, I don’t see the heart of the relationship between your two characters. The stakes in this query seem to be tied to Ryan, but he also seems like a bit of a throw-away character, in that the query here immediately dismisses him as not of interest. What I’m missing is what this story brings to the B&B tale—is it that the gender-bending twist that the Beast is a girl, too? I think that could be enough, but then I’m wondering does Zoe know her sexuality going into this or is it something she’s discovering/fighting/coming to terms with?
I also feel like you need more—not a ton, but enough to anchor your reader—about the curse. Curses feel older, antiquated or fairy tale-like, but the threat here seems to be that someone would put Isabella into a lab, which is very modern and scientific. That could be a really interesting twist on the tale, but I really wanted to know more about the curse itself so that I could make sense of Zoe searching for a way to break it. Is that something Isabella asks her to do? Is it something she’s decided herself to do?
All of which is to say that you don’t need all of this information in a query. Yours is great in that it is short and succinct and to the point, but the thing I think it’s missing overall is character motivation.
By the end of the query, I should have an inkling of who Zoe is as a person. So whatever information you do decide to add to the query should be to build up the characterization of Zoe and, possibly, Isabella. Because the goal is that you want the agent to desperately want to read about this girl’s story.
1 Comment
Melissa Miles · June 10, 2015 at 8:30 am
I look forward to each new day’s offerings! These are quite useful. Thanks to everyone involved for making this happen.
Comments are closed.